New Study Examines Whether Dogs Are Feline-Friendly – or Not

Hoffman’s study, entitled “Dogs’ responses to visual, auditory and olfactory cat-related cues,” was published in the January 2017 Journal of Applied Animal Behaviour Science. “When dogs are waiting for adoption at a shelter, a common question is ‘what is the dog like with cats,” Hoffman says. She explains that standardized assessments exist to assess dogs’ behaviors around humans and other dogs. Currently, however, there is no validated way to predict how a dog in an animal shelter will behave around cats, unless the dog’s previous history is known. “Our study investigated what a cat-friendliness assessment might look like,” continues Hoffman.

To do this, she and her team examined the responses of 69 pet dogs, of a variety of breeds and mixed breeds, when presented with three different stimuli: a realistic-looking cat doll, recordings of cat sounds, and the smell of cat urine. Their findings revealed that dogs are more responsive to the sounds of cats than to the sights or smells of cats. Specifically, dogs with a history of killing or injuring a cat or other small animal spent longer orienting to the cat sounds than the other dogs. There was no relationship between dogs’ histories with cats and other small animals and their reactions to visual or olfactory information.

“As humans, our first thought was to test dogs’ responses to the cat doll because it visually resembles a real cat. However, our findings suggest that dogs are relying more heavily on another sense, hearing. This was surprising since most behavioral assessments focus on dogs’ responses to visual stimuli. Our findings suggest that employing assessments that engage other sensory modalities, especially sound, may provide additional clues about an individual dog’s behavior. Indeed, it may be possible to use audio recordings of cats to assess which shelter dogs are likely to fare well in a home with cats or other small animals,” Hoffman concludes.

Hoffman's study was conducted, in part, with Miranda K. Workman MS ’14, a clinical instructor in the Department of ABEC at Canisius College; and Natalie E. Roberts ’16, and Stephanie E. Handley ’16, graduates of the ABEC program. Canisius is one of 28 Jesuit universities in the nation and the premier private university in Western New York.